UMPIRE SERVICES & APPRAISAL UMPIRE PROCESS
Professional Insurance Appraisal Umpire Services
When appraisers are unable to reach agreement regarding the amount of loss, the appraisal process may require the selection of an umpire. The umpire serves as an independent participant who reviews the information provided and helps resolve outstanding valuation differences.
The umpire’s role focuses on valuation issues and the amount of loss being considered within the appraisal process.
Responsibilities Of An Umpire
An umpire may:
- Review appraisal submissions
- Review estimates
- Review photographs
- Review measurements
- Review supporting documentation
- Conduct inspections when appropriate
- Evaluate competing positions
- Assist in resolving valuation differences
The Umpire Process
Typical steps include:
- Appraisal invoked.
- Appraisers selected.
- Appraisers exchange information.
- Areas of disagreement identified.
- Umpire selected.
- Umpire reviews evidence.
- Inspection performed if necessary.
- Valuation decisions made.
- Award completed.
Selecting An Umpire
An effective umpire is typically experienced in:
- Construction
- Estimating
- Property damage evaluation
- Roofing systems
- Storm damage
- Insurance appraisal procedures
The selection process often focuses on finding a neutral individual capable of evaluating documentation objectively.
